Skip to main content

Understanding the Muslim Malaise


The Islamic world has made many achievements in its history. While the Europen world was in the middle ages, the Islamic world pioneered some progress and innovations, however, this circumstance did not continue. This process starts with geographical discoveries, continued with renaissance, reform, and the Industrial Revolution in Europe. All of this turned European world which is in darkness into illuminated and modern. While everything went well for Europeans, the Islamic world began to go ahead in the opposite direction. After that Muslims began to blame themselves in terms of not being religious and not understanding the Quran well. Initially, they didn't care about the developments which are under the control of European, Muslims tried to live “True Islam” which was experienced over 1400 years ago. Parallel to this, while Europe was leading new technological innovations, the Muslim world had rather not to do anything but focused on their internal problems. Europe starts to dominate the world through these innovations these circumstances dragged the ummah into depression and malaise. It is possible to talk about major reasons for the malaise in the Muslim world. The main reasons for this situation can be grouped into three titles; political, economic, and cultural reasons.
The main reason for this crisis is political. Europe's pioneering role in this movement of innovation has also made it a political sovereign. The way to continue this leadership is to dominate other civilizations, especially the Islamic world. Europe, who benefited from this crisis of Muslims, having successfully colonized Muslims, divided them into many parts and set them one against another. Muslims continue to deal with the internal problems rather than external enemies and also every Muslim government spends the greater part of its resources and energy on securing its own power and achieving a reputation in the outside world without avail. While some of the Muslim countries are under the rule of the western colonialist states, others are controlled by native elites who had already been systematically Westernized. Even more, Western states still continue to intervene in these states foreign meddling occurs in many ways in order to maintain this sovereignty.
The second reason is based on economic reasons. Unfortunately, the members of the Muslim global community are non-developed and backward. The majority of its members are illiterate and have been lacking access to educational facilities. Furthermore, in this case, economic struggle with other countries with high technology becomes impossible. In their competition with local Muslim productivity, the colonialists seek to exclude the market, and they succeed with ease. Additionally, regions with significant agricultural and industrial potential in Muslim lands do not attract investors due to political instability. Consequently, all these economic reasons combined with political instability increases the crisis and the darkness of Muslims.
The last reason results from religious and cultural understanding. Indeed, the regression of Muslims for many years caused the spread of ignorance and superstition within themselves. These evils have led Muslims to superstition, dogmatism, and attach to various charlatans. Instead of facing the realities of the world, some of the Muslims turned their face to the hereafter, others one have found the solution in westernization with semi-reform movements. First of all, a secular system of education was built that taught Western values and methods. The students who educated in this educational system were alienated from Islam and their own cultures. With this new class, all Islamic values started to be questioned. They could not be truly western, nor in could they remain eastern. Today Muslims have become alienated themselves as they become westernized.
Briefly, there are many reasons for this elaborate of Muslims. They originate primarily from political, economic, and cultural elements. The solution is not to emulate Europeans which are the causative factor of the malaise of the Muslim. Muslims should build institutions that lead in science, art, and technology but also they must respect their own history, culture, and values. What can't be imitated is not the institutions of the west, the impossible imitation is trying to have that soul that is not yours. Muslims should be pioneers of innovations by adopting their own past and values.

(This article is inspired by the book Islamization of Knowledge - İsmail R. Faruqi) 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Anthropology From The Past To The Present

As we know, all sciences are good for everybody and it must be objective to create a common knowledge legacy of humanity. Therewith, objectivity is one of the most important principles of science. ' Scientific objectivity expresses the idea that the claims, methods, and results of science are not, or should not be influenced by particular perspectives, value commitments, community bias or personal interests, to name a few relevant factors' [1] . But now or before, can we say this statement is valid for anthropology or all of the social sciences which are based on western ideology? Anthropology with its other name -the study of men- as a general definition helps us to understand ourselves through understanding other cultures.   In western ideology, it is claimed that societies follow the social development stages in which western people are at the top of it. It means the western people are an example of human perfection. Undoubtedly, this theory was inspired by Darw

From Ideal Society to an Ideal Human

Throughout history, human communities have been named as "society,” “nation,” “race,” “people,” and “tribe”. The whole denotations express the unity of blood, race, land, and ownership. In Islamic terminology, the concept of "ummah" replaces all of them. The concept of ummah involves much deeper meanings than racial, regional associations. The word Ummah is an Arabic word that refers to a certain society. Furthermore, it also includes meanings such as path and intention. Islam aimed at social unity by ignoring the discriminatory elements with choosing the concept of the ummah. According to Ali Shariati, the ideal Islamic society is called the Ummah. In this context, the ummah is formed by a common faith and the people who share the purpose. Moreover, this social structure defies today's societies based on racial foundations. The Islamic religion targets "universal brotherhood". The holy book of Islam, the Quran, is a book that aims at removing the ba

A Contemporary Religious Movement: Scientology (1)

The understanding of religion in the middle ages and the reactive stance is taken against a number of scientific developments that led to processes such as the Renaissance, Reform, and the Age of Enlightenment in European history. All these processes have paved the way for the formation of modern sciences and the concept of modernity. In parallel with these transformations occurring in the modern individual and modern society, changes were observed in the field of mentality and truth. Undoubtedly, the most important area in which this change is seen emerges in the "positioning of religion". The "God-centric" understanding was abandoned, and the "human" factor was placed on top of the human-god-nature triangle, and scientific knowledge started to play a dominant role in the life of modern man by overshadowing "divine knowledge". After the processes of modernism and postmodernism, the "human" placed at the top of the hierarchy ha